Macro Resistance and Micro Resistance
I was having dinner a few nights ago with a young screenwriter and a big-time Hollywood literary agent. The writer was joking that her career had stalled on the “C” list.
“If I had you for a year,” the agent said, “I’d get you high on the ‘A’ list.”
The agent was serious, and a serious discussion followed. Most of the talk centered on the politics of career advancement. When I got home, though, I found my thoughts migrating to the craft aspects.
How would a true, knowledgeable mentor elevate a talented writer’s career? How would he advance it one level or two levels higher? What aspects of craft would he accentuate? What changes would he insist upon?
Step One, I think, would be to really hold the writer’s feet to the fire.
The mentor would make the writer truly accountable to her own talent.
- Conception of project.
The young writer comes in with an idea for a movie or a book.
Is the idea good enough?
Is it big enough?
Is it truly original?
Will it attract “A”-level talent? Director? Actors?
The agent/mentor would insist that the writer consider alternatives and variations on the idea. Is Version One the absolute best way to do this? “Okay, the story is about giant spiders invading from Mars. Would crustaceans be better? How about if they came from Venus?”
- Execution of story.
In my own days as a screenwriter, my agents (and they were all good) would, with only minor tweaks, pretty much accept the draft I gave them. That was the version they took out and tried to sell.
Looking back, they should have pushed me harder.
I have another friend, a literary agent who runs her own boutique agency, a really good one. She does exactly that with her clients. She sends them back to the drawing board over and over.
Our theoretical mentor should be just as hard on his young, talented writer.
“You’ve told the story as an action adventure from the female scientist’s point of view. Is this the best way? What alternatives have you considered? Why did you reject those?”
- Maximization of character drama.
“Have we plumbed the detective’s dilemma deeply enough? He’s in love with the lady scientist but he’s conflicted because he has a pet tarantula at home and he finds himself relating sympathetically to the spiders. How can we deepen this issue and make it play most dramatically in the climax?”
Why, in today’s post, am I asking these questions?
Because they apply 100% to our ongoing (sorry, I can’t stop) series, “Reports from the Trenches.”
In other words, they’re the same questions you and I have to ask ourselves when the first draft of our novel or screenplay goes south.
We need to be our own mentors, our own agents, our own editors.
We have to hold our own feet to the fire.
Have we settled (we must ask ourselves) for the First Level version of our story, of our execution, of our characters? Did we grab the first idea and run with it?
Our mentor/agent/editor would force us to be accountable. He or she would demand that we push on to Level Two and Level Three and beyond.
Which brings me to subject of Resistance.
If I were writing The War of Art again today, I’d add a section on the subject of Micro Resistance.
Macro Resistance is the global kind. It’s the self-sabotage that stops us from doing our work, period.
But many of us have beaten that monster. We can sit down. We can bang out the pages.
But Micro Resistance is sabotaging those pages.
Micro Resistance strikes inside the book or screenplay. We’re working, but we’re not working deeply enough. We’re settling. We’re not pushing the action, we’re not considering enough alternatives, we’re not demanding that scenes and sequences and dramatic relationships extract the last bit of juice from their potential.
Micro Resistance is what’s been kicking my butt on this re-do I’m working on.
Why have I not pushed deeply enough?
Because it’s hard work.
I’ve avoided the effort out of fear of failure.
I’ve accepted stuff that a more mentally-tough writer would have rejected.
Resistance, you and I must never forget, is constant and unrelenting.
It fights us in every phrase and every sentence.
It always wants us to settle for the easy, the shallow, the first level.
Do you have that agent, that mentor, that editor who will force you to be true to your talent?
If you do, you’re incredibly lucky.
But you and I need to cultivate that mentor inside our own heads.
We’re the writers. Accountability for our work lies with us.
We have to be that agent/mentor/editor ourselves.
A New Tool to Fight Resistance
Get a new mini-book from Steve every single month.