Go tell the Spartans, stranger passing by,
That here, obedient to their laws, we lie.
Simonides’ epitaph of the Three Hundred at Thermopylae
What was it about this battle, the stand of the 300 Spartans at Thermopylae, that makes it different from all other battles, say, Gettysburg or Trafalgar or Cannae or the Battle of the Bulge?
Why is this one particular standstill remembered? Why are movies still being made, and books written about it, 2500 years after it happened?
Here’s my answer:
In almost every other battle or clash at arms that we can name or remember, the individual warriors, entering upon that clash, believed either that they could win or that they could survive. If, in the event they did happen to die, that was bad luck, faulty strategy, an act of God. But the armies entering the fight believed they would survive, if not prevail.
Not the Three Hundred Spartans.
They were chosen by their king Leonidas, all of them, as fathers of living sons. They knew they were going to die. The whole point of the defense of the pass was that they would die.
The role of the Three Hundred was to model valor and self-sacrifice, not with any hope of victory or even survival, but to inspire and to instill courage into the other Greek states who would take on the Persian multitudes in subsequent battles.
And in fact, that’s exactly what happened. A year later in the sea battle of Salamis and the land battle of Plataea, the Spartans, and the allied Greek cities, including Athens, which contributed mightily, defeated the invaders and drove them back into a catastrophic retreat and withdrawal, thus preserving Western civilization and the ideals of democracy.
But the essence of the defense of the pass at Thermopylae, and the reason why the name alone resonates today as powerfully as it did then, was the fact that the defenders knew their fate going in and they embraced it.
Go tell the Spartans, stranger passing by,
that here obedient to their laws we lie.
A few points to notice about Simonides’ famous epitaph:
No mention of the battle.
No mention of the enemy.
No mention of the war.
No mention of the stakes of the war.
Victory or defeat? We can’t tell from the verses.
No mention of the specific defenders, other than the single word, “we.”
Of course, Simonides knew he could count upon the fact that any Greek reading his lines would know all of the above—who fought there, against whom, and the outcome.
The poet could afford to leave these out.
He could afford to write in the lean, cut-to-the-bone Spartan style.
But what did he leave in?
What the poet chose to express overtly was “obedient to their laws.” Yet even these he did not define. Reading his verses, we might ask, “What laws? Commanding what?”
What does “obedient to their laws” mean in this case? I would translate the phrase as “true to their values” or “faithful to their code of honor.”
In other words, to stand fast and not to yield, no matter what.
To lay down your life willingly.
These were the “laws” the Three Hundred were obedient to. Every Greek reading these verses understood this implicitly.
It was their code of honor too.
And it’s ours, their moral and spiritual descendants, to this day.
But what else did the poet leave out? What did he leave unexpressed, knowing that we, his readers and hearers, would supply it?
He left out the personal stakes for each individual warrior. And the emotion that would precede that ultimate moment.
He left out Fear.
Fear stood over everything.
What were the Spartans’ “laws?” Why were they instituted? To produce what? To stand against what?
We can answer that in one word.
Phobos.
Fear.
The laws were instituted in an attempt to counteract Fear.
It’s also interesting that the poem begins: “Go tell the SPARTANS.” Not the Athenians, not the World — tell the SPARTANS.
William,
When I read your comment, my first thought was, “Of course, because no one else would understand. Everyone else would criticize, condemn, question and belittle the ‘backward thinking Spartans’. You make a great point.
bsn
Steve,
These videos are like the North Star to me. To be reminded of what true sacrifice, true integrity, true honor looks like is both terrifying and inspiring. I’m not one of your readers who questions the validity of the Spartan culture. Would I want to be a Spartan? Most of the time, not at all. I’d prefer to live in Athens. I’m more of a creative. But I am inspired nonetheless. I have spent some time in pretty stark environments, and the irony is they are some of my best memories. Any military person understands this.
What the story of Thermopylae reminds us is that art and culture would have died without the ‘rough men willing to do violence on their behalf’.
I sat on a panel, 10 or 11 years ago. The convention was for non-profits doing good overseas. The breakout in which I sat on the panel was about Afghanistan. There were two others–3 Cups of Tea educator types, and me–the only military guy in the zip code.
The question was about what happens when the military pulls out. I answered, “Well, more female school teachers will have their heads cut off.”
Went over like a lead balloon, but I stand by the assertion. People do not care about the humanities when they are terrified, starving, or ill. There has to be a sense of safety before learning can happen, and throughout the history of mankind–rough men willing to do violence to protect the tribe are required. Maslow’s hierarchy fits with the individual and with nations. It is why we must allow for wealth accumulation before Senegal, Botswana, Peru, any third world country gives a shit about global warming.
No one cares about the future of the planet when they are more concerned with clean drinking water…
I am so grateful for you doing this. It matters.
bsn
Very well said, and astute observations, Brian.
It’s also interesting to me that many overlook the fact that a contingent of Thespians remained behind as well, and died on the field.
Considering “Thespians” is now synonymous with things relating to drama and theater, that’s kind of curious as well.
Indeed, life is a series of choices. Your ‘challenge’ to live by a code – whatever that may be – is among the most profound ideas you have offered.
We are very lucky to know these precious things. Here I know more interesting information, giving me background knowledge. A good website, keep it up, I hope it lasts a long time.
Thanks for this episode and the YouTube video. It’s very interesting to follow each episode. Keep up the good work, you are making very interesting content.
If you are also doing some of these, then the Free vbucks app will play this game once.
Although a country with a low level of education, their solidarity and resilience to fight together cannot be underestimated. It was a power greater than even advanced weapons.
I really enjoyed watching Go Tell the Spartan’s 13 episodes. It was a very interesting and exciting story. The main character, Jesus Christ, is a young man from Nazareth who has been called to be the Savior of the world. I personally recommend https://masterbundles.com/templates/presentations/powerpoint/strategy/ source to download free templates.He is not perfect, but he still is able to do great things for others.
Thanks for this episode and the YouTube video.
حمل بار به همدان
We are very lucky to know these precious things
حمل بار به بوشهر
باربری از ترکیه به ایران
ارسال بار به ازمیر
Useful shares. The information is accumulated to a certain amount.
this is very nice blog
thanks for all this posts
hello boys
this is vvery nice
thanks
thats my boy
thank for sharing
Third-party developers have recently introduced the Honista Apk, which comes equipped with a range of novel features outlined briefly in the following article.
Vencord offers extensive customization options through its built-in CSS editor and prioritizes user privacy, making it a noteworthy addition to the Instagram user experience.
That movie intrigued me more than any other of the Vietnam era. I recall sitting in a university library in 1964 looking at pictures of American advisors in Vietnam. In one pic a rescue crew had brought back a casualty and guys were hosing the blood out of a chopper. Two years later I married a USN pilot who served from 64 to 70. Part of it was in Vietnam, Thailand etc. I remember thinking at the time looking at the pictures – this is not going to end well or at least in military victory for USA. Decades later my hub returned to Vietnam because our middle son was marrying a Vietnamese girl who lived in a village south of Saigon (Ho Chi Minh city). I was ill and could not make it. Every single person in the village turned up for the wedding. It was epic. Husband made a toast translated to Vietnamese – may the life of these children be full of peace and forgiveness. May they never know war or hatred. May we always live together like today to celebrate joy and long life – together. I got to watch it all over computer. The food and beer would fill a warehouse. A decade later the young couple has two sons. I live with them and homeschool here in US. The brides parents came to live with us last year. They help run out little farm effort. The brides dad missing a finger from an incident during the war is in charge of chickens and quail and fruit trees. Anyway — I wish to GOD Almighty our leaders had learned SOMETHING from Vietnam and the idiocy of how we stumbled into it. Only thing is any good that came from it has to include my family – extended family – and fact we now have considerable family in Vietnam who are thriving as well as in US. God is good.
Get the best New Dress Design in Pakistan by Mohagni and discover the finest collection. Our latest collection gives you a stylish and lovely look. Find your desired dress design and start your online shopping now!
Are you looking for the perfect addition to your wardrobe? Adoro’s branded shoes for men are crafted with superior craftsmanship and will help you stand out from the crowd. From classic designs to modern styles, we have something to suit every taste. Our shoes are made from premium materials and come in a range of sizes so you can find the perfect fit. Step up your style game with Adoro’s branded shoes for men!
Chahyay offers the best collection of Ladies handbags online in Pakistan. The best women bag for girls are available in styles and colors online at Chahyay. So, shop for ladies’ bags for kids online in Pakistan from the Chahyay.
Discover The Ordinary serum for your skincare routine at Chahyay. Choose from a range of effective products including The Ordinary Vitamin C Serum and The Ordinary Retinol Serum. Achieve healthier, brighter skin with Chahyay selection of high-quality serums. Shop now for beautiful, radiant skin.
Discover the top women clothing brands in Pakistan at Jamnii. We offer a wide range of Pakistani designer brands that cater to every style and occasion.
Discover the newest range of electric remote control car at The Entertainer. Providing a variety of toy cars for kids that offer hours of engaging and active play. Find the perfect toys for your children online at the Entertainer.
Everything is clear and honest, and the concerns are covered in great detail. The benefits of knowing the facts are undeniable. Does my website generate a lot of revenue from sales? Kindly have a look at this: five nights at freddy’s game
Experiencing debt collection harassment – persistent calls, threats, or abusive language. Filed a complaint with regulatory agencies and sought legal advice. Share your stories and let’s empower each other to navigate these challenges.
Maintaining proper Tajweed during Quran recitation is crucial for preserving the integrity of the sacred text. Regular practice, listening to proficient reciters, and seeking feedback are key to honing Tajweed skills. Patience and dedication are essential as mastery of Tajweed takes time. Incorporating these tips into your practice routine can help you achieve fluency and precision in Quranic recitation & Online Quran Teacher.
Deltaroot excels in penetration testing, assessing IT/OT systems for vulnerabilities. Our expert analysis identifies weaknesses, ensuring robust defenses against cyber threats. Trust Deltaroot to conduct thorough tests and provide actionable insights to fortify your security posture effectively.
Expert Tennis Betting Tips for Beginners offer crucial insights to get started. Focus on understanding player form, surface preferences, and match conditions. Use reliable sources for predictions and compare odds to gauge market sentiment. Track your bets to refine your strategy and enhance your chances of success in tennis betting.
Great insights in this episode! For those who are tennis enthusiasts, you might want to check out Tennis Betting Tips by Stevegtennis. Their expert advice and predictions can really enhance your betting strategies. Thanks for the thought-provoking content!
Episode Thirteen: Go Tell the Spartans is informative and there are a lot of people who are interested in it to get more and more ideas. I saw a lot of people are in need of help and such posts are a great source of information.
“Go Tell the Spartans” is a powerful historical phrase derived from the Battle of Thermopylae, symbolizing sacrifice and duty. It reflects courage in the face of overwhelming odds, reminding us of the bravery of soldiers who defend their land and values, even when defeat seems inevitable.
“Episode Thirteen: Go Tell the Spartans” sounds intriguing, evoking themes of courage, sacrifice, and resilience. Drawing inspiration from ancient Sparta’s legacy, the title hints at a story centered around bravery and unyielding spirit, possibly in the face of great adversity. A captivating and intense narrative seems likely to unfold.
Thermopylae stands out in history for several reasons, particularly the Spartans’ unwavering commitment to their fate. Unlike many battles, where soldiers might hope for victory or escape, the Spartans knew they were facing overwhelming odds against the Persian army. Their decision to stand and fight, fully aware that they were likely to die, speaks to their extraordinary courage and sense of duty.
The epitaph’s phrase, “obedient to their laws,” encapsulates their dedication to Spartan ideals of honor and sacrifice. This willingness to embrace death rather than retreat or negotiate highlights a profound sense of loyalty and bravery, making Thermopylae not just a military engagement, but a poignant symbol of sacrifice for one’s values and homeland.
thanks this is good blog. workplace HR
The transcript for Episode Thirteen: Go Tell the Spartans offers a fascinating glimpse into the narrative depth and thematic richness of the series. The dialogue is sharp and evocative, capturing the tension and emotional weight of the story. Each line is meticulously crafted, drawing viewers deeper into the characters’ struggles and the overarching plot. Speaking of depth and creativity, if you’re someone who enjoys enhancing your digital experience, you might want to explore tools like the
Honista Instagram mod.
For Web3 Telefonie SCUBA divers and desk divers alike the Aquis Date Upcycle is an eye-catching reminder of a sobering reality that affects all of us and it’s encouraging to see Oris continue to support ocean conservation and to partner with those who are actively working to raise awareness for the protection of our oceans.